Nestled in the peaceful countryside of Burlington Flats, New York, stands a remarkable Civil War–era home built around 1860.
Set on 5.51 acres of scenic land, this timeless stone residence perfectly captures the enduring charm of 19th-century craftsmanship while offering plenty of opportunities for restoration and personal touches.
With its striking stone exterior, wide-plank floors, and a sturdy barn nearby, the property feels like a window into America’s rural past — a place where history and natural beauty meet in perfect harmony.
The home spans approximately 2,400 square feet and features three bedrooms and two bathrooms, along with multiple living spaces that blend comfort and historic character.
From the moment you step onto the covered porch and through the French doors, you’re greeted by an inviting interior full of rustic warmth. Inside, wide baseboards, thick stone walls, and exposed details speak to the skilled craftsmanship that defined the mid-19th century.
One of the highlights of the home is its wood-burning fireplace, set in a brick hearth that anchors the main living area. It provides not only a cozy centerpiece for cold New York winters but also a tangible link to the home’s long history — generations have likely gathered here, sharing meals and memories around the glow of the fire.
The living room flows naturally into a large, open kitchen and dining area, where family gatherings and conversations easily come to life.
The updated kitchen offers modern conveniences while preserving a sense of rustic charm. New light fixtures and fresh sheetrock have been added, blending functionality with the home’s old-world aesthetic.
The wide-plank hardwood floors throughout the house are another standout feature — their rich, time-worn patina tells stories of more than a century of footsteps, from the Civil War era to the present day.
Upstairs, the bedrooms provide peaceful retreats, each with their own character and natural light filtering through the windows. Though the home still needs some work to reach its full potential, many essential improvements have already been made, including updates to the plumbing, electrical breakers, pressure tank, and snubber box.
These updates lay the groundwork for a successful restoration, allowing the next owner to focus on bringing the finer details back to life.
Outside, the property’s 5.51 acres are a true delight for anyone who loves open space, nature, and privacy. A small pond glimmers near the edge of the land, adding to the bucolic beauty of the setting.
Majestic old trees dot the landscape, offering shade and a sense of permanence. The home’s secondary, maintained road location ensures a quiet lifestyle, away from the noise of the city but still within reach of conveniences.
The two-story barn, spanning roughly 2,300 square feet, is another gem of this property. It stands as a reminder of the property’s agricultural roots while offering endless possibilities for modern use — from storage and workshops to creative studio space or even a future event venue.
The barn’s weathered beauty complements the stone house perfectly, creating a quintessential New York country scene.
Nature enthusiasts will appreciate the proximity to Texas School House State Forest, which provides abundant opportunities for hiking, birdwatching, and outdoor exploration. For those who enjoy fishing, the Wilber Lake Cooperative Fishing Area is nearby, offering a peaceful retreat for anglers.
Shopping, dining, and additional amenities can be found in the neighboring towns of Oneonta, Norwich, and Utica, all within reasonable driving distance. The historic town of Cooperstown, home to the National Baseball Hall of Fame and the Farmers’ Museum, is also nearby — adding a touch of culture and history to the region’s rural charm.
While this 1860 stone home is being offered as a “diamond in the rough,” it already possesses many of the qualities that make historic homes so beloved: authentic materials, solid construction, and an unmistakable sense of place. With a little vision, it can easily be transformed into a dream country retreat — one that balances the rustic grace of its past with the comforts of modern living.
This property isn’t just a house; it’s a story waiting to be continued. Every stone, every creak in the floorboards, and every breeze that passes through the old trees carries echoes of the past.
Whether restored as a permanent residence, a countryside getaway, or a creative homestead, this Burlington Flats treasure offers a rare chance to own a tangible piece of American history.
For those seeking a peaceful life surrounded by nature and the enduring craftsmanship of another time, this 1860 stone house on 5½ acres stands ready for its next chapter — strong, graceful, and full of promise.
