
44420 Butterfield, Alexandria Bay, NY 13607 is a 5-bedroom, 1-bathroom detached home with 1,126 sq ft of interior space, built in 1895 and set on an 8,712 sq ft lot. Blending rustic style with modern comfort, this home is located on a private island with breathtaking panoramic lake views.
The interior features two fireplaces, including a double that serves both the interior and the exterior deck—ideal for warmth and outdoor cooking. The waterfront features a full-size dock, a dock, and two boats: a 15-foot Yamaha 40HP motor and a 12-foot Nissan 9.5HP motor, as well as a 6HP Johnson outboard motor, which will allow you to use your own motor.
The property is offered fully furnished with work equipment, tools, a chainsaw, and enough other items to allow you to enjoy life on the supply island.
The property is listed for $339,000, with a Zestimate value of $313,600 (range $298,000 to $329,000). The price per square foot comes to about $301.
The property is assessed at $77,500, with an annual property tax of about $1,819. The property was placed on the market o
For more information or to schedule a viewing, please contact the listing agent via the Zillow link below the photos.















Watch Zillow