Key Details
The house is said to have been built in 1895 and designed by Stanford White, a well-known architect (of McKim, Mead & White)
It was described as having 16 bedrooms, 6.5 or 7 bathrooms, and approximately 8,000 square feet of interior space.
The property sits on about 3.75 acres of land, overlooking Stony Brook Harbor with water views.
The listing claims it sold for $999,000.
Caveats & Questions
The source (Historical Homes of America) is not a primary real estate listing or government record, so its accuracy may vary.
I could not immediately confirm the sale through multiple independent real‑estate databases or news outlets.
“Designed by Stanford White” is a notable claim — White was a major name of the Gilded Age, so if true, that would make the property especially significant
Step Back in Time: Own a Gilded Age Mansion Designed by Stanford White for Under $1 Million
Perched high on a hill overlooking the serene waters of Stony Brook Harbor, a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity awaits history lovers, architecture enthusiasts, and dream-home seekers alike.
The majestic Wetherill Estate, built in 1895 by none other than renowned architect Stanford White, has recently changed hands — for the remarkably modest price of $999,000.
This 16-bedroom, 6.5-bath architectural treasure sits on a sprawling 3.75-acre parcel of land in Saint James, New York, offering panoramic views, privacy, and a tangible connection to America’s opulent past.
A Gilded Age Masterpiece
Stanford White was one of the most famous architects of the Gilded Age, best known for his role in designing iconic American landmarks such as The Washington Square Arch in Manhattan and Rosecliff Mansion in Newport, Rhode Island.
As a partner in the prestigious architectural firm McKim, Mead & White, his style came to define the luxury and grandeur of America’s elite at the turn of the 20th century.
The Wetherill Estate is a shining example of his residential work — a mansion that combines Old World elegance with the rustic charm of Long Island’s North Shore.
While many of White’s more famous works were commissioned by wealthy industrialists or used as public monuments, the Wetherill Estate was designed as a private family home. And it shows — every line, window, and room feels intentionally crafted for both beauty and livability.
Breathtaking Views and Endless Potential
Set high above the harbor, the estate offers sweeping views of Stony Brook Harbor, one of the most picturesque and historically significant bodies of water on Long Island.
Imagine sipping coffee on the veranda while the early morning fog rolls across the harbor, or hosting an elegant garden party under the late summer sky with sailboats drifting by in the distance.
The home itself spans approximately 8,000 square feet, providing ample space for both restoration and reimagination. While it retains many of its original features — including detailed woodwork, grand staircases, and ornate fireplaces — it also presents a unique opportunity for its new owners to bring it into the modern era while preserving its historical integrity.
For lovers of old homes, the potential is immense. The floor plan includes 16 bedrooms, many of which could be transformed into luxurious guest suites, artist studios, or home offices.
The 6.5 bathrooms, though dated, provide a solid foundation for luxury upgrades. And with nearly four acres of land, there’s room to expand with gardens, a pool, or even a guest cottage.
Historical Charm Meets Modern Opportunity
While the sale price of $999,000 may seem like a steal for such a storied estate, the home does need significant work. Like many homes of its age and size, deferred maintenance and updates will likely be required to bring the property up to modern standards.
But for the right buyer — someone with vision, resources, and a deep appreciation for history — the Wetherill Estate represents a rare chance to own a piece of architectural history.
Zoning laws in the area could also allow for creative uses of the property beyond a private residence. A boutique inn, a cultural center, or an artist retreat could all be viable projects — so long as local regulations are carefully followed.
Its location in Saint James, part of the Town of Smithtown, means it’s just a short drive from both Stony Brook Village and Port Jefferson, offering convenient access to restaurants, shops, and ferry service to Connecticut.
A True Legacy Property
What makes the Wetherill Estate truly special is its story. This isn’t just a house — it’s a living piece of American architectural history.
Built during an era of extravagant mansions and artistic flourishes, designed by one of the country’s most acclaimed architects, and nestled in a timeless landscape of natural beauty — it’s the kind of property that simply doesn’t come around often.
Restoring a property like this is more than a real estate investment; it’s a preservation of culture. The new owners aren’t just homeowners — they’re stewards of the past, with the rare privilege of shaping the future of an American classic.
Conclusion
In a real estate market increasingly dominated by cookie-cutter developments and sky-high prices, the Wetherill Estate stands apart — offering not just space and scenery, but soul.
With its roots in the gilded elegance of the 19th century and its eyes toward the future, this magnificent home is ready for its next chapter.
Whether it becomes a restored private residence, a boutique historic venue, or an artist’s paradise, one thing is certain: whoever walks through its doors next is stepping into something truly extraordinary.
